AronT on December 9th, 2002

Israeli’s love to repeat a bon mot that Abba Eban coined: “The Palestinians never miss an opportunity to miss an opportunity.” But according to this article by Amos Elon, a well known Israeli historian, that expression actually applies to the Israelis.


Elon is hardly a flaming leftist. He is an ardent Zionist. While I don’t agree with everything he writes (I think his analysis of Camp David and Taba miss the mark), he still makes some startling assertions for someone deep in the Zionist camp:

  • The early Zionists ignored the existence and legitimate demands of the indigineous Arab population and their nascent nationalism [in fact to this day many israelis and Jews like to say there is no such nation or people called Palestinians]
  • Israel ignored many opportunities over the years to resolve the conflict with the Arab world
  • The colonization (Elon’s words) of the West Bank was the most disastrous decision ever made by Israeli leadership and poses a real threat to the continued existense of the State.
  • “The vast settlement project after 1967, aside from being grossly unjust, has been self-defeating and politically ruinous. ‘We’ve fed the heart on fantasies,/the heart’s grown brutal on the fare,’ as William B. Yeats put it almost a century ago in a similar dead-end situation in Ireland. The settlement project has not provided more security but less. It may yet, I tremble at the thought, lead to results far more terrible than those we are now witnessing.”